Possible New Space Camp Logo

The place where campers hang out after a long day in the sims.

Moderator: Vincent

User avatar
Vincent
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 1167
Joined: Mon Jan 01, 2001 12:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Vincent »

I'll say finally that, at the very least, they should use it for the Space Camp for Educators program. I think it works well for that program as well.
Mdanner423
Counselor
Counselor
Posts: 158
Joined: Sat Jul 12, 2003 8:29 pm
Location: Oak Island, NC

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Mdanner423 »

I don't hate it... But I don't love it. I'm glad it resembles the old logo so much but agree the astronaut man could be better.

Maybe it's just nostalgia but I don't want a big change!
-Matthew
User avatar
Richasi
Top Gun
Top Gun
Posts: 506
Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 9:35 pm
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Richasi »

Wow! The one based on the Astronaut Hall of Fame logo is great!
(and the second merged with the Official Camp logo just makes it!)
Space Camp • June 11-16, 1989 - Session 31 - Martin Marietta
Space Academy, Level 1 • June 16-21, 1991 - Session 24 - BDM
Adult Space Academy • September 26-28, 2003 - Session 52 - Discovery
Alumni Camp • June 14-17, 2007 - Session 38 - Challenger
SpaceCanada
HabForum Junkie
HabForum Junkie
Posts: 2125
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2004 2:07 pm
Location: Canada

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by SpaceCanada »

The redesign form the video isn't the best... but the suggestions posted here look great. The shuttle is still very symbolic of spaceflight, and one that children still know today. Another capsule design would be suiting but without being popular and well-known yet, I don't think it would work. The child reaching for the stars seems most suiting to me for many reasons. :)
Last edited by SpaceCanada on Wed Nov 07, 2012 3:07 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Jennifer -
Youth ASA 6-Day 1998 1999
Adult ASA 8-Day 2004; Alumni 2007, CSC 2013, 2015, 2017
User avatar
Hotdog
Top Gun
Top Gun
Posts: 902
Joined: Wed Dec 06, 2006 9:11 am
Location: Rocket City, USA

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Hotdog »

Thanks for all of your comments and complements on my "reach for the stars" concept. Now if we could wrap this entire thread up and send it to the mothership, that would be great :)

Although I have a feeling, based on what little feedback I got from the mothership, that it may already be too late and that their minds are set on their decision to go with the re-hashed version of the current logo with the "anthropomorphic" sci-fi spaceman.
4-time Space Camp/Academy alumni
1989, 1991*, 1992, 1994
*Right Stuff Award Winner
User avatar
Hotdog
Top Gun
Top Gun
Posts: 902
Joined: Wed Dec 06, 2006 9:11 am
Location: Rocket City, USA

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Hotdog »

Just spotted the hideous aquanaut logo on the Space Camp website being used for the robotics program.

Image
4-time Space Camp/Academy alumni
1989, 1991*, 1992, 1994
*Right Stuff Award Winner
User avatar
Vincent
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 1167
Joined: Mon Jan 01, 2001 12:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Vincent »

It's funny you made this comment now. I've just heard that the logo, slightly tweaked, has been approved to replace the old logo.

I'll write it up with more detail (and commentary) on the front page soon.
User avatar
p51
HabForum Junkie
HabForum Junkie
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sun Feb 19, 2012 12:36 am
Location: 2558 miles from Space Camp
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by p51 »

Nope. I don't like it one @#*&ing bit... :x
They did clearly tweak it a little though from the original released.
From:
Image
To:
Image
Skidmark
Space Academy: 2012, 2013 and 2014
Advanced Space Academy: 2016 and 2018

Undefeated for winning mission patch designs!
Official Space Camp Ambassador
SpaceCanada
HabForum Junkie
HabForum Junkie
Posts: 2125
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2004 2:07 pm
Location: Canada

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by SpaceCanada »

The new one is slightly improved from the original. The person doesn't look so much like a blob; it has a bit more definition. The orbiter logo will still be true to my heart, but I get which direction they are taking it - away from the shuttle and towards future missions like the ISS, Orion, and Mars. I'm still not keen on it but I don't want to be judgemental. I look forward to Vincent's update on the home page. Will other Space Camps (Canada, Turkey) be changing the logo as well?
- Jennifer -
Youth ASA 6-Day 1998 1999
Adult ASA 8-Day 2004; Alumni 2007, CSC 2013, 2015, 2017
User avatar
Vincent
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 1167
Joined: Mon Jan 01, 2001 12:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Vincent »

As franchisees, I would think they would have to (eventually) adopt any logo changes...
User avatar
Hotdog
Top Gun
Top Gun
Posts: 902
Joined: Wed Dec 06, 2006 9:11 am
Location: Rocket City, USA

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Hotdog »

As someone who designs logos for a living http://www.facebook.com/matneygraphics, allow me to post some more detailed thoughts now that the new logo is "official".

Space Camp basicly had two options: 1. Design a completely new logo or 2. Refresh the existing logo. A new design would be more costly, more difficult to create and be harder to phase in. This totally new and different concept would have to be a home run and make everyone forget about the previous Space Camp logo that's become so recognizable. It's likely they did not have the budget to pursue this option in the proper manner. Refreshing the existing logo is cheaper, and if the changes are minimal enough and executed correctly, it can be phased in without too much commotion. A bonus of a logo refresh is that you get to keep the brand recognition generated by having the same design in the market for so many years already.

Having been in this situation before, a designer like myself can tell you exactly what happened. The management went with the cheaper Option 2 and gave it to a staff member or friend of the staff to execute, with the orders to "change the shuttle to an astronaut figure in an anthropomorphic space suit." There is nothing wrong with Option 2 or these types of limitations. In the hands of the right creative person with a strong skill set, it can be done. But the refreshed Space Camp logo we're stuck with now was not not dealt with in a creative way. Visually, you can tell it was executed by someone with a skill set that is not on par with the previous logo.

But forget about how badly drawn the cartoon astronaut is for a moment. Let's just look at the figure himself. He is standing, which implies gravity, and in space you are weightless. So unless you throw in a moon or martian landscape, you're just showing kids what they can do at home for a lot less money: dress up in a space suit and run around pretending to be an astronaut. And we can't throw in a lunar or martian landscape because we are limited to using the red flag stripes of the existing logo background. So, Strike One in this attempt at a home-run logo by showing the astronaut figure standing.

Strike Two is the fact that the figure is idle and not doing anything. He is not interacting with his environment in any way. He is completely irrelevant to everything surrounding him. The old Space Camp logo we all know and loved was great, but there is always room for improvement. One way to improve it might have been to make the subject (in the previous case, the shuttle) interacting more with its' environment (that was the basis for my mission patch you see in my avatar). With this logo refresh, we have the opportunity to explore ways that could possibly improve the design in this type of way. How cool would it be if the astronaut figure could be doing something that shows what kids actually do at Camp (either in the literal sense or a more symbolic way like "touching the stars")? This is the area where you hit home runs as a creative designer.

Strike Three is just the poor execution of the drawing of the astronaut figure. Like Vincent said in his post, each logo should look better than its predecessor. This is correct, even if it's just a refresh of the existing design. At the very least, It should appear as if it was drawn and designed by the same person who did the orignal, even if it wasn't. In the case of the new logo the mothership has seen fit to go with, we have a step backwards in visual strength.

I could go on and on about this, but that will have to come at a later time. I'm concerned at how lightly the powers-that-be are taking this. They are weakening their brand and I'm not sure they realize the importance of the task at hand. There is still plenty of time to reverse course before too much damage is done. They need to get some real creative people on this and right the ship.
4-time Space Camp/Academy alumni
1989, 1991*, 1992, 1994
*Right Stuff Award Winner
SpaceCanada
HabForum Junkie
HabForum Junkie
Posts: 2125
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2004 2:07 pm
Location: Canada

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by SpaceCanada »

The article on the Hab1 home page is very well written, Vincent! I was thinking much the same, minus the male perspective.
- Jennifer -
Youth ASA 6-Day 1998 1999
Adult ASA 8-Day 2004; Alumni 2007, CSC 2013, 2015, 2017
User avatar
Vincent
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 1167
Joined: Mon Jan 01, 2001 12:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Vincent »

SpaceCanada wrote:The article on the Hab1 home page is very well written, Vincent! I was thinking much the same, minus the male perspective.
Yes, it's a vital consideration that others may have missed!

Good thing I'm here to point it out! :D

Seriously though, it'll happen. A lot.
User avatar
Conan
Pathfinder
Pathfinder
Posts: 258
Joined: Tue Jun 19, 2007 1:08 pm
Location: Michigan

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Conan »

I had my brother look at the new logo. He is the founding professor of the Brand Center at Virginia Commonwealth University and appears regularly as a branding consultant on tv news shows. His response was: "The new logo is not very good. They could do so much better. "

That from a professional. Kelly O'Keefe if you want to look him up.
Conan
1988-Adult Lev. I
1994-Parent/Child
1996-Adult Lev. II
1997-Adult AC
1998-P/C
1999-Pilot/Copilot
2000-P/C FL
2000-Adv. Adult Acad
2001-Adult AC
2004-Pilot/Copilot,
2007-Adult Alum.Reunion
2009-P/C
2014 - Adult 4-Day
2015 - Advance Adult Academy
User avatar
p51
HabForum Junkie
HabForum Junkie
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sun Feb 19, 2012 12:36 am
Location: 2558 miles from Space Camp
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by p51 »

"Hmm. You're right, that is pretty weak..."
-My wife (who's always right about everything, just ask her)
Skidmark
Space Academy: 2012, 2013 and 2014
Advanced Space Academy: 2016 and 2018

Undefeated for winning mission patch designs!
Official Space Camp Ambassador
User avatar
Vincent
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 1167
Joined: Mon Jan 01, 2001 12:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Vincent »

Conan wrote:I had my brother look at the new logo. He is the founding professor of the Brand Center at Virginia Commonwealth University and appears regularly as a branding consultant on tv news shows. His response was: "The new logo is not very good. They could do so much better. "

That from a professional. Kelly O'Keefe if you want to look him up.
For the lazy:

http://www.kellyokeefe.org/
http://www.okeefebrands.com/

Tell your brother that his company has a mighty fine logo! :D
User avatar
Conan
Pathfinder
Pathfinder
Posts: 258
Joined: Tue Jun 19, 2007 1:08 pm
Location: Michigan

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Conan »

I talked to Kelly about the logo a little more this weekend. He said that it is truly awful, and he too would be willing to help them with a better one if they were willing. I told him that we already had a member who made the same offer and designed a great logo. He did say that Cal Tech tried to institute a new logo that was bad recently and people were able to kill it by going on social networking such as Twitter and Facebook. He thinks that this is a strategy that we should try.
Conan
1988-Adult Lev. I
1994-Parent/Child
1996-Adult Lev. II
1997-Adult AC
1998-P/C
1999-Pilot/Copilot
2000-P/C FL
2000-Adv. Adult Acad
2001-Adult AC
2004-Pilot/Copilot,
2007-Adult Alum.Reunion
2009-P/C
2014 - Adult 4-Day
2015 - Advance Adult Academy
SpaceCanada
HabForum Junkie
HabForum Junkie
Posts: 2125
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2004 2:07 pm
Location: Canada

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by SpaceCanada »

There's yet another logo printed in the 2012-2013 program brochure (page 10), used for the robotics camp. The online version has been updated to the new person logo but the old one had an orbiter, satellite, and Canadarm. I will see if I can scan it and post it one of these days. I noticed it whilst looking through the brochure that was sent with my USSRC store order in December.
- Jennifer -
Youth ASA 6-Day 1998 1999
Adult ASA 8-Day 2004; Alumni 2007, CSC 2013, 2015, 2017
User avatar
p51
HabForum Junkie
HabForum Junkie
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sun Feb 19, 2012 12:36 am
Location: 2558 miles from Space Camp
Contact:

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by p51 »

I showed the new logo to someone I went through art school with yesterday, who has designed logos for several companies with a ad/branding agency in New York. Talking with him on the phone when he got my e-mail, he stiffled some laughter than busted out giggling when I told him he wasn't offending me at all with any reaction. "Seriously, this is what they came up with?" he asked. He agreed that the new logo should probably keep in the same theme as the old one for brand recognition due to the target market but asked, "what's this supposed to be, pale Gumby goes to space?" I ran my first idea of the same logo background with a traditional rocket going up through the center and he agreed that was similar to his first idea as well. Hotdog, we liked all three versions of your ideas. "All of those are much better than what they wound up with," he said. He wondered who's wife or kid at SC designed this, adding, "I've seen a lot of jobs my firm has had with large companies suddenly get terminated because someone's wife or kid desinged something that a suit on the top floor of the client's building wanted to use instead. I'd bet this is something like that."
SpaceCanada wrote:I noticed it whilst looking through the brochure that was sent with my USSRC store order in December.
I'll have to look that up when i get home tonight, I have the same one from my ill-fated SC jacket order saga, but I never noticed any new logo stuff (but I didn't pay much attention, I was looking mostly for any changes in the Adult program portion).
Skidmark
Space Academy: 2012, 2013 and 2014
Advanced Space Academy: 2016 and 2018

Undefeated for winning mission patch designs!
Official Space Camp Ambassador
User avatar
Steve
Pathfinder
Pathfinder
Posts: 214
Joined: Wed Feb 29, 2012 6:48 pm
Location: Murfreesboro Tennessee (83 miles from Space Camp)

Re: Possible New Space Camp Logo

Post by Steve »

Does any one know what brought on the change of logo? Looks like we need to step back to the past, before we blast off to the future!! :lol:
Adult Space Academy 2012 Team Columbia
Adult Space Academy 2013 Team Discovery
Adult Space Academy 2014 Team Discovery
Adult Space Academy with Astronaut 2015 Team Discovery
Official Space Camp Ambassador
Volunteer at US Space & Rocket Center
Post Reply